Depersonalization Support Forum banner
1 - 20 of 73 Posts
G

·
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
It's important to know before beginning any discussion of Narcissism that the word is VERY over-used and you can't even get agreement among the psych professionals as to what it means, so confusion is guaranteed to abound. EVERYone on this earth has narcissistic traits and there is nothing wrong with that. It's healthy narcissism i.e., high self-esteem, etc.

When I use the word on this Board, I am usually talking about a narcissistic DISTURBANCE, or disorder. That does not mean that the person loves him/herself too much, but exactly the opposite. Narcissistic Disturbances arise when the person is SO fragile, and has such dark and horrible self-hatred at their core, that they need to create a false SELF image, a tricky way of convincing themselves that they are very powerful and/or special all as ways of hiding from how bad they really feel about themselves underneath.

(also, please know there is so much more to all this, lol. I'm just giving you a TINY gist of the concepts here)

Anyway, people with narcissistic disorders often experience DP states. The reason is multifold, but here are SOME of the things we do in our thinking that sets the stage for DP and obsessive anxiety states:

We usually have two (or more) very distinct images of ourselves. We might be full of self-hate or self-anger, but underneath that, we feel very superior to most people. We have higher standards, expect more, demand more, settle for less, etc. In that self-righteous position, we are convinced that if we just didn't have (i) these terrible symptoms, or (ii) this terrible situation at home, or (any other unacceptable predicament) then we would be able to BE as extraordinary as we think we are.

We are constantly holding onto what we think we COULD be (one day, someday, if only, when x happens, etc.). And we DEFINE ourselves by our Potential, not by our reality.
We are very reactive to SHAME. We become enraged easily over feeling embarrassed or ashamed...and we turn it against ourselves, we become very self-hating as if we failed ourselves and now deserve to suffer.

In order to cope with the big discrepancy between what we ARE and what we WANT TO BE, we have to really do some fancy juggling. And what we juggle is reality. We are constantly living half-in and half-out of reality, but we probably didn't see that until we had a breakdown. Then the DP experience really shows us.

One of the most crippling traits of this type of personality is that we have great difficulty NOT knowing something. We hate learning we want to already KNOW. We hate having to work TOWARDS anything we think if we know what where we want to be, we should already BE there. We hate uncertainty if there is doubt or confusion, we invent an answer and convince ourselves we DO know, even though we may change our minds a hundred times, each time we are positive we KNOW.

We need other people desperately and we hate that fact so much, we pretend we need nobody. Our goal is to be totally self-sufficient, totally self-contained. And anytime the other person in a relationship with us shows their own DISTINCT differences, we freak out. We want total merger or no relationship at all. Total agreement or no discussion at all. Black and white. Nothing in between.

We tend to adore someone or think they're worthless.

We tend to feel on top of the world, or at the bottom of hell.

We refuse to learn how to live in the middle-ground and to ENDURE living even when we're not feeling great. We EXPECT to feel great, and if we don't, we are so enraged that we shut down as if going on strike, lol

And at the core of all this is the feeling/fear that we are nothing. Literally, totally nothing.

When someone doubts that they are even a human, or worth anything, they tend to create symptoms that require them to constantly CHECK themselves (for health problems, for sanity, for a variety of am I feeling real right now? reasons)

We are TOO focused on the sense of self because of a deep and massive terror that we really are nothing.

And in the mix, we tend to become hypochondriacs (imaging we have all kinds of illnesses, or thinking our heart is about to stop, or that we can't breathe if we're not observing our own breathing, etc.)

We tend to dissociate (or have dp/dr) because we are constantly scanning the environment and ourselves for reality checks.

We tend to do very little with our lives, because we are waiting for something waiting for ourselves to feel good enough or powerful enough to be able to instantly achieve what we think we want. We refuse to take steps, to build..we are so fragile that the first disappointment makes us not even want the goal anymore. We are so afraid we can't cope with reality that we live inside our imaginations as consolation.

Make any sense?

My point here (for the 2 or 3 people still reading, lol) is that NO amount of self-observation or self-obsession is going to cure the symptoms, because they were created by the mind for exactly that reason to DISTRACT you and make you watch self as a life activity.

IF a person recognizes him/herself in this thread, and they decide to do some therapy, the goal is to get to know yourself and take a look at some of the deeper fears and misguided defenses that got you into this mess. Recovery and/or working through all this is NOT quick. It takes years, guys.these personality types are VERY hard to treat because we are stubborn and resentful and controlling. And underneath, we're terrified that we will find some Self that we cannot live with. Talking helps, therapy helps. And in the meantime, force yourself to STOP the self-monitoring and the unrealistic expectations and life should get easier.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
544 Posts
Good post.

Whilst I can see myself in much of that description, thinking about it I really don't think I "fit" the category properly.

Sure, I might think that I can become good or proficient at something, but I use that belief to work towards the goal, rather than in opposition to it. I'm also not very "black or white", thinking wise.

There's one thing that you didn't mention here, Janine, that I always see written with descriptions of narcissistic traits: a lack of empathy. I don't know whether I'm right or wrong in attributing that to narcissism, but if I am that's another thing that I and others here don't seem to suffer from.

What I'm saying is, people, although you may see yourself in many of these descriptions, be careful. You may be looking for things that "match" and ignoring what does not. I for one don't believe that not everyone here needs long-term therapy to overcome personality "disturbances" at all, it can be much simpler than that and was for me.

Enough of my rambling. I might post something more coherent when I'm less tired.
 
G

·
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
Tricky tricky concept - "empathy". The mainstream info you'll read (websites, etc.) on Narcissism Personality are very misleading. I'm talking about a disturbance within SELF (that's what makes it "narcissism" not the fact that the person is self-centered, etc.). The "I am so great" beliefs are COVERS (desperately and rigidly held covers) for very painful fears that lurk constantly underneath.

Folks with these kinds of personality structures CAN appear highly empathic, but it's "empathy with a twist" - we are highly alert to any signs and signals from other people because we're always on the lookout for rejection, surprise, the unknown, domination, etc. We "read' people (or try to constantly) as a form of self-protection. I actually had my analyst tell me once that I "had sonar!" lol....

But empathy at its core implies a kind of SHARED experience that we tend to not believe exists. We can be compassionate and believe WE can feel or understand what the other person feels, but when the tables are turned, we assume that NOBODY else on the earth has ever felt precisely what we feel. We feel constantly on the outside of normal human experience (either imagining we feel more/better/deeper, or worse/more fragile/weaker).

So when we, in turn, are empathizing with someone else, we are trying to put ourselves in that person's POSITION, but we are very resistant to trying to fathom that the other person is MORE than a "situation" - he is also a PERSON - with his own set of feelings and thoughts and "take" on things. We tend to see other people as "like we are" or "not at all like me" - all relating to ME, one way or another. That's not self-centered in a "aren't I fantastic?" lol....but because we are constantly needing to refer BACK TO SELf, as if to reaffirm its existence. Even before/without DP, we can't just BE. We don't just presume Self, we monitor it, control it, watch it, love it, hate it, reject it, glorify it....we live through the experience of being a self WHILE KNOWING we are living and experiencing as that self. "Regular" people would have no clue what this means, and would probably say I'm nuts, lol

Thank you for enjoying today's narcissism lecture, lol...(also, I'm not trying to convince ANYone that they are a narcissistically structured personality. I'm writing a book on nar and DP and this is just a very pronounced interest of mine right now, and it's applicable to mySELF. I am NOT contending that everyone with DP is of this personality type. I'm just exploring the connection more in depth).

All comments, ideas certainly more than welcome!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
19 Posts
I am a confirmed "narcisstic" personality type and your discription is spot on. I use to have shame surrending my diagnoises until I researched it and found discriptions similar to your own. Alice Miller also talks about it well too. I have read Sam Varkins stuff on it but am way passed that type of thinking on the subject. On a last note, there is hope of recovery!
 
G

·
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Yep, spot on yourself. I suspect Vaknin is a wounded lover of some narcissistic or something close to it - he's got a very personal vendetta going - clear as glass.

And Alice Miller is a very good writer to read on the subject, esp. Drama of the Gifted Child.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
544 Posts
I will definitely buy the book once it's out. This is a really interesting topic for me. A few more points.

First, what actually gives rise to these kind of personality structures? Is it something that "just happens" through a set of circumstancial events in life producing a certain outlook? Or is it rooted in childhood, in how one's parents related to the child when they were young, and how that upbringing was divergent with the reality of the world "out there"?

Second, if this type of personality isn't giving rise to symptoms, and I'm sure in many cases it doesn't, is there anything "wrong" or even "undesirable" about it? Is it objectively "worse" to have these traits, are they always maladaptive? Or do they have there advantages?

Also, my (limited) knowledge of narcissism doesn't really stem from any knowledge of Psychology, but more from my readings around History and especially psychological evaluations of historical figures and the like. It seems that a lot of famous and interesting figures have had these traits. The most obvious one is Hitler, who in nearly every psychological discussion I've read gets dubbed as having strong narcissistic features: not seeing other people as "real" in the sense that he was; feeling he had a sense of "destiny", that he was somehow "special"; yet at the same time wanting to shut out anyone or anything that threatened his idealized view of himself, as if he had some deep-rooted and underlying fear that he really wasn't what he made himself out to be.

Aside from the "good" and "bad" of narcissistic traits, it seems that they can produce some very "interesting" people.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,197 Posts
Monkeydust, I hope you don't mind my jumping in here:

"First, what actually gives rise to these kind of personality structures? Is it something that "just happens" through a set of circumstancial events in life producing a certain outlook? Or is it rooted in childhood, in how one's parents related to the child when they were young, and how that upbringing was divergent with the reality of the world "out there"? "

TT: You seem to be asking if we pattern our relationships with the world (including ourselves) on the way significant people in our early life related to us. Am I correct?

"Second, if this type of personality isn't giving rise to symptoms, and I'm sure in many cases it doesn't, is there anything "wrong" or even "undesirable" about it? Is it objectively "worse" to have these traits, are they always maladaptive? Or do they have there advantages? "

TT: Wouldn't a person who never accomplishes anything and wants success without having to work hard have a pretty miserable time of it?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
544 Posts
TT: You seem to be asking if we pattern our relationships with the world (including ourselves) on the way significant people in our early life related to us. Am I correct?
Yeah, sort of - although I'm not so much asking about "relationships with the world" as I am about specific narcissistic personalities/traits.

TT: Wouldn't a person who never accomplishes anything and wants success without having to work hard have a pretty miserable time of it?
Yes.

But the mistake is to assume that all people with narcissistic traits and a tendency to "sit back" knowing their "great" will actually do this. Many, I think most, probably don't. I'm pretty sure the majority are able to lead "normal" or "good" lives.
 
G

·
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
You're BOTH wrong, and insensitive to boot. Narcissists (that is SUCH a misnomer) don't just sit back and do nothing and expect everything, nor are they able to live "good (going by your definition, that probably means happy)" lives. They are driven to succeed and to accomplish as much as they can without completely destroying themselves, and even then sometimes they cross that limit. But, they're never satisfied with what they accomplish.

Alexander the Great is the perfect example. He wasn't satisfied with conquering just Greece or Persia; he was compelled to conquer all of the known world.

Yours truly,
XEPER

P.S. I'm being ignored, aren't I?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,197 Posts
That's the problem with labels, don't you think? I think what I was talking about was what Janine called "narcissistic disorders," (ND) where as one could have narcissistic personality without having a disorder.

Perhaps that's the difference we're talking about.

A person with a ND might feel he didn't want to work hard to achieve what he wanted, but a narcissistic personality who could work hard might do just fine. Maybe that's Monkeydust's point.

But labels are just handles we use for communication. There's a spectrum of all human behavior and it's just for convenience of communication that we use these labels. I don't think they help people find an accurate location for themselves on the spectrum, and I wonder if we should be thinking about labels at all.

Why not think about, "Can I do anything about how I feel?" or something similar. Know what I mean, Xeper?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
441 Posts
XEPER said:
I'm being ignored, aren't I?
If the other persons don't want to comment it doesn't mean they ignore you. But maybe they do. Why is this bad? It doesn't mean that you are wrong or that you don't deserve attention. Because I think that this is what you feel by saying "ignore" (that you are wrong or that you don't deserve attention). In conversations, just state your opinion, if noone else likes to talk about it, then.. "oh well". It happens to me a lot :)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
544 Posts
Yeah, I see what you're getting at Sojourner. But then I also think that the majority of people here who are suffering problems partially due to narcissistic personality traits don't have them to the extent as to have a "personality disorder" (I don't like that term anyway).

XEPER, sorry if I got it all wrong here. I'll make it clear that I don't know what I'm talking about when it comes to Psychology, so I'm just speculating, trying my best and what have you.

I can't say whether you're ddescription is the "right" one because I don't know enough about it. However I can say that I "fit" that description - working hard but never being satisfied with enough - almost perfectly.

And you're not being ignored lol.
 
G

·
Discussion Starter · #19 ·
Just go to this site, it has all the information you could ever want about NPD (although, it, too, is somewhat biased against narcissists, so take care to sift through it to filter out the opinions):

http://samvak.tripod.com/msla.html

Yours truly,
XEPER

P.S. That ignoring thing was a joke, and I'm sorry if I offended you.
 
1 - 20 of 73 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top